Q about plagiarism

crushPMP's picture

 

30. 

You have been managing a project to write and publish 7 books. The books content was written by a team of contributing writers from your client's organization. Six of the seven books have been printed and distributed, the seventh has just been sent to the printer, and the project closeout work has begun. While walking through the office you overhear one of the writers mentioning that she made extensive use of an online source of information for the sections she wrote. When you get back to your desk you do some spot checking of this writer's work and discover that quite a bit her text was copied word for word from this information source. You are unaware of any existing agreement authorizing the use of this material on your project. What do you do?

  1. Ask the writer what else she has copied and see about getting approval from the owner of the plagiarized information.

  2. Notify your project stakeholders immediately.

  3. Since the books have already been printed, there is no use reporting to anyone.

  4. Call the printer and cancel the last book that has just been sent.

 

35. 

Your company took over the management of a project for another company that went out of business. To minimize disruptions related to the transition, your company hired a number of the employees from the other company. One of these employees has delivered a 300 page document a week ahead of schedule. However, while walking past his desk you notice he has a document opened on his computer with the logo of his former employer. You suspect that some of his work may have been taken from documentation that is the property of the other company. What do you do?

  1. Report this to your project stakeholders immediately.

  2. Determine if any materials belonging to the other company have been copied.

  3. The copyright material is owned by the client, for whom you are working so this is not a copyright issue.

  4. Do nothing. Because the company is now out of business, out no one now owns the copyright on that material.

30. A

35. B

Thanks

Jai

First  A

Second B

crushPMP's picture

I have a few follow-up questions here, Mr. Scordo has not done an excellent job in clarifying these subtle differences and his answers are contradictory, at time, to his own prior questions - Sometime he says to check with the "guy" (confront), sometimes he say report to management, sometimes he says confirm your own doubts first before blowing the whistle (and your job, ofcourse) and sometimes he say's just stay mum.

So...........

When would you go talk to the "guy" directly (confront him) and check/clarify your doubts before escalating

When would you go top of his head and report your suspision to the Sr. Management (his boss, etc)

When wold you come back to your desk to ascertain your suspicions, before blowing the whiste

Let's say PMI contacts you (a PMP certified Project Manager- AVP) to help investigate a plagiarism case on your reporting manager (also a PMP certified Sr. Project Manager - VP), do you forward all the emails as proofs that your VP was indeed involved in plagiarism or....?

Let's say FBI contacts you (a PMP certified Project Manager- AVP) to help investigate a misdemeanor (felony) charges on your reporting manager (also a PMP certified Sr. Project Manager - VP), do you forward all the emails as proofs that your VP was indeed involved in theft or....?

Appreciate your thoughts on this.

When you have evidence, then you notify stakeholders.

In the first case you have evidence that the document was plagiarised as you looked it up and hence you have information to back your case.

In the second case, even though you noticed the document with the logo of another company it is not enough evidence to be presented to the stakeholder as that document was on the guys desktop.So you confront the guy and get more information.

Hope this helps.

30. D because, before taking the action of investigation and seeking the copyright approval, you need to stop printing becasue it has already reached the printer and incur any cost of printing you should stop printing. In my opinion, if it was not sent to printer yet, then option A would have been appropriate I guess.


I would like to know the tight answers anway...thanks!


35. B, since none of the other options are not so convincing.


Regards


CN Patil

 

Patil , I am joining with  you 

 

30. First stop the work and save additional expenses to print the book. Later we can have investigation and solve the issue by getting copyright.

35. You just "suspected" only. First find whether he has copied  the material.  Then you can take appropriate action. 

 

 

crushPMP's picture

Correct answers are B and B. So I guess, noone really knows when to report, when to investigate, when to complain, when to "do nothing" ...